NY BBQ GUYS SET UP

VOLUME 1: Why I Built My Dream Smoker (250 Gallon Reverse Flow Smoker)

Fire & Steel Chronicles: Volume 1

Why I Built My Dream Smoker

Sometimes the best equipment is the one that exists only in your mind – until you decide to make it real


A few years back, I decided it was time to build my dream smoker. Not buy one. Build one. That's what we do at Own the Fire™ - we build the equipment that doesn't exist anywhere else.

After decades of cooking and 20+ years in professional kitchens, I knew exactly what I wanted. Started sketching - pages of details accumulated over a lifetime of cooking, notes from countless overnight cooks, solutions to problems that kept me awake at 3 AM.

Time to turn sketches into steel. Every measurement, every angle, every weld had a purpose born from real experience.

The Journey to This Moment

You have to understand – I'd been cooking my entire life. Started in professional kitchens at 16, spent 20+ years learning from chefs who treated temperature control like a religion. Then another 25 years in marketing, but never left the fire behind. Every weekend, every holiday, every chance I got – I was cooking.

I'd owned them all:

  • Entry-level offset smokers that leaked smoke like sieves
  • Cabinet smokers that worked until they didn't
  • Kamados that held heat but limited capacity
  • Pellet grills that felt like cheating
  • Even built a cold smoker from a halibut shipping box (surprisingly effective)

Each one taught me something. Each one had limitations that made me think, "If only..."

The Moment of Truth

The decision came after yet another overnight cook where I found myself managing fires at 2 AM, adding water pans for humidity, rotating meat because of hot spots, MacGyvering solutions to problems that shouldn't exist.

I started shopping seriously. Looked at all the big names. Incredible equipment. But nothing had everything. Each had compromises. At those prices, I didn't want compromises.

"What if I just built exactly what I want?" The thought wouldn't leave.

Found a 250-gallon propane tank. Clean, thick steel, perfect foundation. Started sketching. Really sketching – not dreams, but plans. Measurements. Angles. Airflow calculations I'd learned from an old-timer who built competition smokers in Texas.

The Build

Bought a welder thinking I was ready. First bead on quarter-inch steel taught me otherwise. Upgraded to a bigger machine immediately. No room for amateur hour when you're building something to last forever.

The Critical Decisions:

Quarter-inch steel throughout – Not 3/16". The extra thermal mass means stability. Once this thing gets to temperature, it stays there. Wind, rain, snow – doesn't matter.

Firebox with 1-inch insulation – I smoke through Northeast winters. Wanted consistent control regardless of outside temps. Wind, snow, single digits - doesn't matter anymore. The fire holds steady.

Reverse-flow design with calculated baffle – The plate runs exactly 82% of the chamber length. Too short and you get hot spots. Too long and you choke the draft. This creates true heat equilibrium.

Dual dampers – One on the firebox, one pulling from the smoke chamber. Creates actual zones when needed, perfect circulation when opened.

Stack at grate level – Not at the top like most designs. Eliminates the temperature gradient between where your meat sits and where most thermometers read. What you see is what you get.

Removable ash system – Heavy gauge trays that slide out completely. Sounds minor until you've fought ash buildup during an overnight cook.

The First Cook

First real test was for a crowd. 10 pork butts. 12 racks of ribs. Trays of mac and cheese, baked beans, over 100 jalapeño poppers.

I'd cooked for crowds before, plenty of times. But watching this thing handle that volume without breaking a sweat - that was different. Everything fit. Everything cooked evenly. No shuffling meat around, no hot spots to manage, no fighting to maintain temp with that much thermal mass going in.

Made quick work of what used to be a juggling act. That's when I knew the build was worth every hour in the fab shop.

The Revelation

Look, I've always been able to cook. Made competition-level BBQ on equipment held together with wire and hope. But this smoker showed me what happens when your equipment matches your knowledge.

No more working around problems. No more compensating. Just cook.

This is what OWN THE FIRE™ really means. Yeah, this smoker is incredible. But I earned it by fighting with garbage equipment for decades first. Every problem I solved the hard way went into this design.

The NY Fire & Steel Academy teaches this progression. FOUNDATION members learn to master whatever equipment they have. ADVANCED members understand the why behind modifications. ELITE members get my complete blueprints – not to copy, but to understand the thinking so they can design their own solutions.

The Unexpected Bonus

Had a pile of leftover steel after the build. Good steel. Heavy gauge material that cost real money. The fabricator asked what I wanted to do with it.

That question led to my next build – a Santa Maria grill that would open my eyes to a completely different approach to live fire. But that's a story for next time.

Your Equipment Journey

Whether you're fighting with a cheap offset from a big box store or contemplating your dream build, remember this: Every limitation is education. Every workaround is wisdom.

The gap between my first smoker and this 250-gallon masterpiece isn't just money and steel – it's a lifetime of accumulated knowledge made tangible. When you understand the why behind every component, you can make any equipment perform better.

The Fire & Steel Way (OWN THE FIRE™):

  • Master what you have
  • Understand why it works (or doesn't)
  • Modify with purpose, not hope
  • Build or buy your next level with earned knowledge
  • Remember: Fire responds to knowledge, not price tags

This smoker produces perfect BBQ not because it's expensive, but because every inch was informed by experience. Your journey to equipment mastery starts wherever you are right now.

Continue Your Journey

This is just the beginning of the Fire & Steel Chronicles. Each month, we share the critical moments and hard-won insights from a lifetime dedicated to fire.

Ready to accelerate your own equipment mastery?

Join NY Fire & Steel Academy →

FOUNDATION ($10/month) Master any equipment with professional techniques

ADVANCED ($25/month) Understand the engineering behind great BBQ

ELITE ($50/month) Get complete blueprints and direct guidance

Next Chronicle: How leftover steel from this build became a Santa Maria grill that changed everything I thought I knew about live fire.


Mike Riddle
Founder, NY Fire & Steel Academy
Forged in professional kitchens. Tested in competition. Shared with respect.

P.S. That 250-gallon smoker has produced thousands of pounds of perfect BBQ since that day in the fab shop. But its real value isn't in what it cooks – it's in what it represents: a lifetime of knowledge made tangible in steel. That's what OWN THE FIRE™ is all about – not the equipment you own, but the mastery you've earned.


© 2025 Own the Fire™ | Subscribe to the Fire & Steel Chronicles

Back to blog